----- Original Message -----
To: John (Jack) R. Venrick
Sent: Wednesday, March 14, 2012 7:24 PM
Subject: Re: Breaking News. Big Court Victory at 9th Circuit.

Jack; In Montana they've that in spite of a hunting season the wolf population is increasing.  As with many environmental issues the organized groups have the attorneys and the money to tie things up in court for years.  It has been proven that environmental issues have created more government intrusion into our lives than any other thing.

From: John (Jack) R. Venrick
Sent: Wednesday, March 14, 2012 5:41 PM
To: Undisclosed-Recipient:;
Subject: Fw: Breaking News. Big Court Victory at 9th Circuit.

Here is some good news for fellow Montanan's and Idaho cowboys..
Jack Venrick
www.FreedomForAllSeasons.org - Table of Contents
1. Mission Statement
2. Natural Law & Natural Rights
3. Unalienable Rights vs. Inalienable Rights 
4. Organic Laws of The United States of America
5. The British Common Law
6. The U.S. Constitution That Never Was
7. Current Property Battles -Taking Back Our Rights
8. Freedom From Alternative Energy Myths
9. Freedom From Critical Area Ordinances Myths
10. Freedom From Fish Myths
11. Freedom From Endangered Species Mythomania
12. Freedom From Environmental Extremism
13. Freedom From Government Cover Ups - The 9-11 Hot Engineering Facts
14. Freedom From Government Roundabout Nonsense For Humans & Fish 
15. Freedom From Illegal Aliens in Government 
16. Freedom From "Man Caused" Global Warming Myths
17. Freedom From Rails To Trails Takings
18. Freedom From Rural Cleansing BY Global To Local UN Agenda 21
19. Freedom From The State of Washington Constitution That Never Was 
20. Freedom To Keep & Bear Arms 
21. Freedom From ALL Tax Takings Upon The Natural Born State Citizens 
22. Freedom To Own Land With Allodial Rights
23. Freedom To Own Property W/O TYRANNY - Embattled Owner Stories
24. Freedom From The unFederal unReserve
25. Freedom From King County WA Municipal Corporation - The Great Imposter 
26. Must Read Must Subscribe Must Support Must See
27. Freedom From Water Takings
28. Freedom From De Facto Laws (New)
29. Freedom From Municipal Corporations, i.e. Evil Empires (New)
30. Freedom From The Brotherhood of Darkness (New)
31. Freedom From Park Takings (New)
32. Freedom From Mainstream Media Monopoly Lies (New)
33. Jack's Prose From The Heart
34. About Jack
----- Original Message -----
Sent: Wednesday, March 14, 2012 3:16 PM
Subject: Breaking News. Big Court Victory at 9th Circuit.

Breaking News. Big Court Victory at 9th Circuit.

Big, Big News.
30 minutes ago, we found out that we have won in court when it comes to wolves and wolf delisting.  The ruling by the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals in San Francisco clearly supported the legality of the Congressional action to delist wolves in the Northern Rockies.  The opinion, written by Judge Schroeder, dated March 14, 2012, ruled that Section 1731 (the wolf bill) was constitutional and that this action by Congress to delist wolves in the Northern Rockies was fully legal.  This is a huge victory for wildlife conservation and will allow wolf management to continue in Montana and Idaho.  It also protects Wyoming's legal victory and leaves the door open for a Wyoming delisting later this year.
As many of you are aware, Big Game Forever and other conservation organizations, including partner organizations Sportsmen for Fish and Widllife and Mule Deer Foundation are parties to this litigation.  
Detailed Analysis
This particular legal challenge attacked various aspects of the constitutionality of the wolf bill in Congress.  This particular case began last year in Judge Molloy's court in the Western District of Montana.  Judge Molloy ruled that Congress has full authority to amend its own laws, including the Endangered Species Act, and that the delisting by Congress was constitutional.  The case was appealed to the 9th circuit, where the constitutionality of Section 1731 was once again challenged.  The court also ruled that Congress did amend the endangered species act through this action to the extent it was inconsistent with the Congressional delisting language.  While it is entirely possible that this case may be appealed to the Supreme Court, the victories at the district court level and at the 9th circuit are a great sign.  We have believed throughout this process in the strength of our position and the legal arguments supporting that position.  To this point, the courts have agreed with our position.
Here is a quote from the ruling:
Appellants’ arguments that Section 1713 is a repeal rather than an amendment must fail for a similar reason. Congress did not repeal any part of the ESA. Rather, Congress effectively provided that no statute, and this must include the ESA, would apply to the 2009 rule. Congress thus amended the law applicable to the agency action.
Appellants also contend that the meaning and effect of the 2009 Rule as reissued under Section 1713 are unclear, and that ambiguity prevents the court from finding an amendment. We cannot agree. The meaning and intended effect of Section 1713 are perfectly clear. The partial delisting was to take effect within 60 days, with no court review or interference....
...Finally, we observe that while Section 1713 bars judicial review of the reissuance of the 2009 Rule, the 2009 Rule does provide standards
by which the agency is to evaluate the continuing viability of wolves in Montana and Idaho. See, e.g., 74 Fed. Reg. 15,123 at 15,186.
Review of any regulations issued pursuant to the Rule or of agency compliance with the standards, does not appear to be restricted.
Section 1713 itself, however, ordering the Rule to issue without regard to the laws that might otherwise apply, is entitled to be enforced.
The bottom line is that once again, the courts have ruled in favor of wolf delisting.  Wolf management will continue in the Northern Rockies by state fish and game agencies including regulated hunting by sportsmen.
Thank you for your ongoing support.  We will continue to keep you apprised of developments as they arise.
A great victory for healthy wildlife populations and for our outdoor heritage.

No virus found in this message.
Checked by AVG - www.avg.com
Version: 10.0.1392 / Virus Database: 2113/4871 - Release Date: 03/14/12