----- Original Message -----
Sent: Saturday, July 30, 2005 8:58 AM
Subject: [Capr-discussion] FW: Jay Lehr,Ph.D. : How to Fix the Endangered Species Act


Subject: Jay Lehr, Ph.D. : How to Fix the Endangered Species Act


The Heartland Institute - How to Fix the Endangered Species Act - by Jay Lehr, Ph.D.


How to Fix the Endangered Species Act

Written By: Jay Lehr, Ph.D.
Published In: Environment News
Publication Date: August 1, 2005
Publisher: The Heartland Institute

Who among us does not love warm fuzzy mammals? Some of us even like slimy reptiles and insects, and we all love critters who take to the air or swim in the sea.

On average, humans are natural-born animal-lovers, and we quite naturally want to do what we can to protect them and their habitat. Alas, the Endangered Species Act (ESA) has never been an effective way to do that.

Using the ESA, the federal government tried to protect endangered species in its usual "command and control" manner, punishing people who discovered their land harbored a rare and vulnerable animal by imposing restrictions on how the land could be used. Under the ESA, most folks are better off looking the other way--or worse, finding ways to make the endangered species leave or "disappear."

The ESA is popular with radical environmental activists not because it actually protects animals, but because it allows the activists to sue landowners and government agencies to stop development. The results, intended or otherwise, are unjust violations of private property rights, interference with science-based listing of species, obstruction of worthwhile projects, lost access to valuable resources, dangerous mismanagement of government-owned land, and economic hardship for rural America.

Help, thankfully, could be on the way.

The Property Rights Foundation of America, under the leadership of President Carole W. LaGrasse, has worked diligently for more than a decade to protect individual freedom against the excesses of environmental activists and rogue government agencies. The foundation has developed a reasonable alternative to the ESA that the public will accept. Its recommendations are as follows:

If the nation's Founding Fathers were here today, they would include all these provisions in any legislation proposed to protect endangered wildlife. Proof of this is the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution: "No person shall be deprived of life, liberty or property without due process of law, nor shall private property be taken for public use without just compensation."

Animal lovers and freedom lovers should not be divided over the best way to protect animals without endangering individual liberty. For the sake of animals and property owners everywhere, let's have the courage to follow LaGrasse's lead.

Dr. Jay Lehr (lehr@heartland.org) is editor of science reference books including McGraw-Hill's Standard Handbook of Environmental Science, Health, and Technology, and science director for The Heartland Institute.

This list is for discussion of property rights issues and related subjects. It is provided by Citizens Alliance for Property Rights, but message content is the responsibility of the sender, not CAPR. Do not infer that posters are officials, members, or even friends of CAPR. This is an unmoderated list. Anything you send to the list will go immediately to all subscribers, unless  the filters think it may be spam. Please observe the common sense rules of civil discussion.

Subscribe to our main list (Capr-announce) to receive meeting announcements, etc. from CAPR. Those items will not be sent to this list.

Capr-discussion mailing list